Has this ever happened to you? You buy ruleset after ruleset and although some of them play really well, and each one has some great mechanisms not one has the right 'feel'. Over the years we've played a lot of WRG Horse and Musket and for a period of time the Brothers were dedicated Shako fans. But for a variety of reasons these fell by the wayside.
In the last year or two several new sets have been available and the boys have all been willing to give them a shot(pun intended). We tried Beneath the Lilly Banners by the League of Augsburg which weren't too bad. In recent weeks we tried the new offering by the Foundry Napoleon and found the firing, melee and morale rules to be simple and really effective. We had a few strange situations due to the command and control rules, but that could have been my fault through misinterpretation! So we tried again...and got the same strange result. Although they look great and the information in the book is great, I'm not sure if we'd use them as our regular set. We've also tried the Crusader publishing set Rank and File. Now these were a very fast set. Once you start losing more than a stand or two from your units, things go downhill very fast in terms of morale! We used my ACW figures in 25mm and it was a quick, easy game with a result in around 2-3 hours. With 8 players and only one person having read the rules, not a bad effort. Finally, Warlord Games new 'Black Powder' rules arrived in the mail a few days ago. We haven't tried them yet, but when we do I'll keep you posted!